Editorials

Editorial: ChatGPT: Challenges, Opportunities, and Implications for Teacher Education

by Torrey Trust , Jeromie Whalen & Chrystalla Mouza
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Interest in Artificial Intelligence (AI) has increased dramatically since the launch of ChatGPT in November 2022. While ChatGPT has captured the imagination of students and educators alike, several concerns have also emerged. In this editorial, we first discuss challenges and opportunities associated with the use of AI in K-16 Education broadly. We argue that the best way to address challenges and inappropriate uses of AI is by focusing on inclusion rather than exclusion. Thus, we discuss potential uses, risks, misuses, and opportunities associated with ChatGPT. We conclude with implications for teacher education, providing a series of recommended AI integration practices for teacher educators.

Mathematics Education

Mathematics Teachers’ Participatory Patterns Between Face-to-Face and Virtual Professional Learning Environments

by Robin Keturah Anderson & Martia Williams
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

This article reports on how mathematics teachers connect face-to-face and virtual professional learning communities by expanding the notion of lurker and broker within both environments. Through an analysis of 18 interviews with K-12 mathematics teachers, categories of participation are presented to describe the nuances between the ways mathematics teachers connect learning experiences across learning environments. This article provides examples of the ways mathematics teachers leverage learning within one space to broker information in the other. Methodological and practical implications of this research are discussed. Methodologically, this article presents the usage of artifact-stimulated recall during interviews to promote reflection of virtual learning interactions. Practically, this article seeks to push the field of mathematics teacher’s professional learning beyond traditional forms of learning to see the value of informal learning in virtual spaces.

Learning Mathematics with Mathematical Objects: Cases of Teacher-Made Mathematical Manipulatives

by Steven Greenstein & Eileen Fernández
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Access to maker technologies has catalyzed and amplified the possibilities for creating physical materials that are responsive to the needs of students. Opportunities for design and fabrication of original mathematics manipulatives have been incorporated into the teacher education program at Montclair State University. Participating preservice elementary teachers design and make original mathematics manipulatives. Three case studies examine ways in which this process enhances students’ mathematical reasoning, sense-making, and understanding. The designs created are made available through links to the open source Educational CAD Model Repository, enabling others to replicate the objects described.

Science Education

Using Simulated Classrooms to Examine Elementary Teachers’ Perceptions About, Attention to, and Use of Formative Feedback to Improve Their Ability to Facilitate Science Discussions

by Jamie N. Mikeska, Jonathan Steinberg, Pamela S. Lottero-Perdue, Dante Cisterna, Devon Kinsey & Heather Howell
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

The purpose of this research study was to examine in-service teachers’ perceptions about, attention to, and use of two different types of written formative feedback designed to support them in developing their ability to engage in one core teaching practice: facilitating discussions that engage students in scientific argumentation. This core teaching practice has been nominated as important for building students’ scientific literacy and has been perennially difficult for teachers to learn how to engage in successfully. This study used an online, simulated classroom made up of five upper elementary student avatars as the practice-based space where the participating in-service teachers facilitated two science discussions. Following the first discussion, each teacher received one of two types of written formative feedback (namely, specific feedback or scoring level feedback) based on their discussion. Findings indicated that the teachers perceived both types of feedback as useful and strongly attended to areas of improvement suggested in the written feedback, regardless of feedback condition. Study results suggest that the use of specific or scoring level feedback can serve as one valuable mechanism to support improvement when using online simulations with elementary science teachers.

Using ePortfolios as an Authentic Assessment Tool for Integrated STEM Professional Development

by Debbie Friench, Brad Rhew, Sean Hauze & Sophia Dorsey
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Electronic portfolios (ePortfolios) are used in collegiate science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) courses and in preservice teacher education, yet there is a dearth of research on the use of ePortfolios for in-service teacher professional development (PD). This article presents the results of using ePortfolios as both a model for teachers to incorporate in their classes and an evaluation tool for an integrated STEM PD. Participants for this study were K-16 faculty members who participated in the National Science Foundation-funded STEM Guitar Faculty PD Institutes. Data were obtained from three sources: faculty participants’ ePortfolios, alumni retrospective survey responses, and focus group data. Emergent themes included the importance of being willing to try new things, new skills learned, students’ ability to build guitars, and identifying curricular connections to the guitar. Quantitative survey responses are reported using descriptive statistics. Two thirds (67.65%) of faculty members referred to their portfolios as they implemented the program. Over half showed their ePortfolios to their students (56%) or other teachers or administration (59%). Over a quarter (27%) of teachers used ePortfolios in their classroom. These results have implications for PD providers. ePortfolios an informative and useful evaluation tool for PD providers. They are useful for faculty members beyond the PD.

Objects to Think With

Learning Mathematics with Mathematical Objects: Cases of Teacher-Made Mathematical Manipulatives

by Steven Greenstein & Eileen Fernández
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Access to maker technologies has catalyzed and amplified the possibilities for creating physical materials that are responsive to the needs of students. Opportunities for design and fabrication of original mathematics manipulatives have been incorporated into the teacher education program at Montclair State University. Participating preservice elementary teachers design and make original mathematics manipulatives. Three case studies examine ways in which this process enhances students’ mathematical reasoning, sense-making, and understanding. The designs created are made available through links to the open source Educational CAD Model Repository, enabling others to replicate the objects described.

 

General

Editorial: Design Pillars for Technology-Infused Teacher Preparation Programs

by Kevin J. Graziano, Teresa S. Foulger & Arlene C. Borthwick
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

This introductory editorial is a brief explanation of the history that led to the special issue of Contemporary Issues in Technology and Teacher Education – General Section. It discusses the difference between technology infusion and technology integration. It then expands on Foulger’s (2000) four pillars to a technology-infused teacher preparation program, and the special issue includes four articles that individually examine each pillar. These pillars include the following: (a) technology integrated curriculum, (b) modeled experiences, (c) practice with reflection, and (d) technology self-efficacy. Written by 19 authors who are considered experts in the field of educational technology, this special issue offers practical guidance and recommendations to assist teacher educators with program development that supports technology infusion and prepares preservice teachers and in-service teachers to use technology effectively.

Curriculum Design for Technology Infusion: A Continuous Collaborative Process

by Melissa Warr, Shannon O. S. Driskell, Elizabeth Langran, Chrystalla Mouza & Denise A. Schmidt-Crawford
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

In this article, the authors discuss technology integration curriculum in teacher preparation programs, focusing on key elements of both the curriculum and curriculum development process. Specifically, they highlight the need to develop a coherent teacher preparation program founded on shared values and practices and responsive to change. When considering technology in the teacher preparation curriculum, this means integrating technology content and practices throughout the program. Research is discussed on the efficacy of touchpoints, or opportunities for integrating technology in the teacher preparation curriculum, including technology-focused and subject-specific courses and opportunities for practicing teaching with technology in field experiences. Finally, key elements of a technology infusion approach are highlighted and program design incorporating a continuous, collaborative process is suggested to support ongoing improvements to effective technology infusion.

Design Principles for Modeled Experiences in Technology-Infused Teacher Preparation

by Yi Jin, Jon M. Clausen, Angela Elkordy, Kiersten Greene & Michael McVey
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Modeling is a widely adopted and frequently used strategy to prepare teacher candidates for technology integration. However, whether modeling as a strategy alone is enough for technology-infused teacher preparation programs is questionable. Therefore, the purpose of this paper is to describe an investigation of how teacher educators model technology use in various settings. Our research utilized an integrative literature review methodology to establish search and inclusion criteria. The authors initially screened 674 papers published between 2012 to 2022. A secondary review included 65 articles for full-text analysis. Results show that ample empirical evidence demonstrates the positive impacts of modeling while simultaneously emphasizing that modeling alone is not enough. Furthermore, there are quantitative and qualitative disparities in the modeling practices of faculty and cooperating teachers. Overall, the literature review underscores the need for a more intentional approach to designing learning experiences that model technology integration. The authors summarize a review of literature as research-based design principles, implementation strategies, and competencies teacher educators need to be excellent at modeling. The design suggestions will be helpful for program designers, teacher educators, and those supporting field experiences who wish to contribute to building technology-infused teacher preparation programs.

Technology Infusion and the Development of Practice: The Quest to Create Digitally Able Teachers

by Debra R. Sprague, Nicole M. Zumpano, Jayson W. Richardson, Jo Williamson & Lucy Gray
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

The third pillar of technology infusion is practice, providing numerous opportunities in multiple settings for teacher candidates to practice teaching with technology and to reflect on their experiences. Drawing from sociocultural theories of learning and change, this article offers a theoretical justification of this pillar and unpacks how infusing practice-based technology preparation will improve new teachers’ ability to use technology in their classrooms. The authors discuss multiple types of practice, both in the teacher education courses and in K-12 field experiences. They argue that teacher preparation programs have been shifting to practice-based approaches for over a decade. However, not all preparation programs have adopted practice-based approaches that support the vision of a technology infusion approach. The article concludes with a discussion of design recommendations for practice elements of technology-infused programs needed for success.

Teacher Self-Efficacy in Technology Integration as a Critical Component in Designing Technology-Infused Teacher Preparation Programs

by Mia Kim Williams, Rhonda Christensen, Dennis McElroy & David Rutledge
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

This article focuses on factors related to supporting the development of teacher candidates’ self-efficacy as critical components in designing technology-infused teacher preparation programs. Through a synthesis of relevant literature, the authors present information about elements influencing teacher self-efficacy in technology integration (TSEinTI) such as environments, attitudes, beliefs, intentions, support, policies, and resources. Findings describe the connection of TSEinTI to the experiences in teacher preparation programs through which teacher candidates gain the necessary knowledge, skills, and dispositions to enable the successful integration of technology in their future classrooms. Additionally, findings reveal the influence of program culture that can support teacher candidates’ growth as they progress through a technology-infused approach to teacher preparation. The authors summarize recommendations for teacher preparation programs in the context of designing program-wide and program-deep technology-infused experiences to support the growth of candidates’ teacher self-efficacy in technology integration.

Editorial: Design Implications for Technology-Infused Teacher Preparation Programs

by Teresa S. Foulger, Kevin J. Graziano & Arlene C. Borthwick
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

In this concluding editorial, the editors summarize design considerations, as presented by the coauthors of the articles in this special issue, for the four pillars of a technology-infused teacher preparation program: (a) technology integration curriculum, (b) modeled experiences, (c) practice with reflection, and (d) technology self-efficacy. They then offer additional, practical suggestions on how to initiate technology infusion in preparation programs and briefly discuss an adoption process to influence change toward an infused-technology approach that involves higher education, PK-12, and other stakeholders.

Current Practice

The Perceived Benefits of Coaching in Online Literacy Clinics

by Barbara Vokatis & Thor Gibbins
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Educating literacy educators in online teacher preparation programs is an area in need of research. As online literacy teacher programs become more prevalent, it will become increasingly important to study the benefits and challenges of various online literacy clinic designs. This study investigated the perceived interactions between tutors and external coaches in online practicum courses to identify what kind of learning impact the presence of coaches might have on future literacy educators. Grounded theory analysis of tutor and coach interviews and tutor course reflections, supplemented with field observations, highlights three distinctive features of perceived benefits of coaching involved: (a) improved reflection and achievement; (b) better collaboration; and (c) being present in the joint activity. The findings also call for more collaboration between online literacy educator preparation and instructional technology coaches and programs.

The Placement Dilemma: Leveraging Technology to Improve the Student Teacher Placement Process Through Participatory Action Research

by Catherine Snyder, Jane Oppenlander, Nicki Foley & Leanne Goldberg
Full Article PDF Show Abstract

Clarkson University is home to a 30-year-old, graduate-level teacher education program which includes a student teaching placement. The placement process is one of the most time consuming aspects of the work done in the teacher education program. In order to minimize time spent placing student teachers and increase the level of service provided to those who require additional assistance, the teacher education program designed a prototype optimization software system to match student teachers with mentors. This optimizer is based on programming principles used in popular software applications individuals might use to find a relationship match. Rather than matching individuals for dating purposes, this model matches individuals based on their student teaching attributes. The software considers student teacher preferences, experience, and academic performance. It also accounts for factors related to mentors such as teaching experience, mentoring experience, school setting, and location. In an initial demonstration, the prototype software was tested with a sample of five student teachers and compared to the actual placement decisions made by the program faculty. The initial results showed strong agreement with the decisions made by program faculty. The research team used the Participatory Action Research process to tackle an adaptive problem that required many sets of expertise and an iterative research cycle. This article includes the results of this project along with challenges experienced in its development and next steps.